Reassessing the Strategic Imperatives in Healthcare Human Resources

the glaring disconnect in how healthcare workers are treated must be addressed. A healthcare setting isn’t merely another profit-driven entity where everything is boiled down to numbers on a balance sheet. Instead, it’s a place where people serve other people, often in life-saving capacities.
A hospital’s primary focus should always be on the people within its walls, not just its outward appearance.

Who Really Runs the Show in Hospitals?

When we think about who’s most active in a hospital, who comes to mind? Definitely nurses, doctors, medical assistants, care providers, and clinical staff. They’re the ones on the front lines, working directly with patients every day.

But when it comes to who gets paid the most, the picture looks quite different. Surprisingly, the CEOs and healthcare administrators – the ones behind the scenes – often get the biggest paychecks. They’re followed by physicians, then nurses, other clinical staff, and lastly, the care providers, who spend so much time directly helping patients.

Does that seem right to you? Even a 5-year-old might say it’s not fair. The basic rule should be: the harder you work, the more you should get paid. It’s a simple and fair principle.

I can confidently speak on this topic because I’m currently studying healthcare administration. In fact, once I complete my doctoral course, I’ll become a healthcare administrator. At present, I work as a medical interpreter in a healthcare organization. One day, I was taken aback when I discovered that our CEO’s salary exceeded 6 million dollars.

Disparity among Staffs

While I fully recognize that CEOs and administrators put in long hours, often working around the clock, the wage disparity, when compared to frontline nurses, is staggering. In our studies as healthcare administration students, our primary focus is on understanding how to support healthcare organizations and their workforce. The goal? To ensure better patient care. That’s the heart of our education and training.

Indeed, as healthcare administrators, our role is primarily supportive; we’re not the primary caregivers. It’s perplexing to note that while most hospitals in the United States operate as non-profits with a clear mission to provide quality care and better the community, this commitment isn’t always reflected in their treatment of staff.

How can a CEO, earning millions, take breaks at their leisure, while some nurses can’t even attend to their basic needs because they’re prioritizing patient care? Such disparities raise questions about how hospitals genuinely value their staff in practice versus the ideals they express in their mission statements.

Back to the Fundamentals

It’s time to speak out with a fervent voice: the glaring disconnect in how healthcare workers are treated must be addressed. A healthcare setting isn’t merely another profit-driven entity where everything is boiled down to numbers on a balance sheet. Instead, it’s a place where people serve others, often in life-saving capacities.

The primary objective of healthcare administration should be to bolster and back the clinical workforce, not to pocket hefty paychecks from profits. I’ll go as far as to say that if hospitals prioritize profit over care from an administrative standpoint, such a mindset is unequivocally unethical. And why is that?

Healthcare workers are not machines. They are dedicated professionals treating individuals, often in critical moments, to save lives. Such workers deserve respect, and their intrinsic motivation to serve in healthcare must be recognized and nurtured. The role of administrators should primarily be to support this dedication, not to pursue profit-driven strategies that lead to staff cuts or diminished care quality in an attempt to save on salaries.

Just as there were movements to bail out auto companies and financial institutions during their times of crisis, a similar approach should be taken with hospitals. If we prioritize industries that produce cars or manage money, why not prioritize those institutions that safeguard our health?

---

Case

I recall an incident when my daughter had a prolonged stay in a hospital. During that time, a new CEO introduced a series of changes. One of the most notable was the decision to shorten the operating hours of the main hospital cafeteria, resulting in its closure by 6:00 p.m. This move effectively eliminated the night shift for the cafeteria staff, leaving nighttime healthcare workers and patients’ families, including myself, without any food options during those hours. The hunger I felt on those nights was both tangible and unexpected in a healthcare setting.

What was even more surprising was the subsequent renovation of the perfectly functional cafeteria, transforming its interiors to resemble upscale cafes. This was accompanied by unnecessary renovations to the hospital hallways, which were already in good condition. Both the staff and I were taken aback by these changes, significantly when essential services like the cafeteria were curtailed under the pretext of budget constraints.

Such decisions raise serious questions. How do emergency room staff, urgent surgery teams, and others working through the night sustain themselves? If the budget was tight, how was there money available for non-essential renovations?

These actions paint a clear picture of the CEO’s priorities, leaving one to question the direction in which he is steering the hospital.

Misplaced priorities of some hospital administrators, where aesthetics and appearance are prioritized over the well-being of healthcare workers.

---

What is the primary function?

It’s disheartening to see that, in some healthcare institutions, aesthetics and the physical appearance of the facility are given more importance than the well-being and needs of the healthcare workers. These are the very individuals who are on the front lines, ensuring patient care. Such misplaced priorities not only affect staff morale but can also impact the quality of patient care. A hospital’s primary focus should always be on the people within its walls, not just its outward appearance.

Shifting

I firmly suggest a restructuring of healthcare administration salaries. There’s a pressing need to reduce the wage disparity. Any savings or balance achieved should prioritize increasing the numbers of clinical staff, enhancing their benefits, and bolstering their support systems. The focus must be on those who directly impact patient care.

Our vision and ethics must align properly. We need to first ensure that our healthcare team receives quality care and support. Only then can we expect them to deliver the same level of care to patients? How can we anticipate excellent patient care from workers who aren’t treated well?

Doctors and nurses often find themselves in a challenging position, caught in the middle. On the one hand, they face stringent quality measures and rigorous training requirements imposed by the administration. On the other hand, they’re tasked with providing top-tier care to patients. With these mounting pressures and without adequate support, how can we expect healthcare workers to thrive?

Sharing idea

Here’s a Suggestion: Rethink the human resource strategy in alignment with the organization’s mission and vision, focusing on the workers rather than just the patients. A revamped human resources strategy should prioritize those who spend the most hours with patients. Compensation should align with this principle.

We all recognize a universal truth: the importance of respecting life. We know that the United States goes to great lengths to rescue its citizens when they face challenges abroad. This reflects the nation’s core values and ethics. Similarly, it’s time we extended this principle to support and rescue our healthcare workers within our hospital settings.

Related Link

https://www.vox.com/policy/2023/2/24/23610762/hospital-ceo-nurses-salary-study-north-carolina